The short answer
For most shading, soft graphite pencils in the B range are the most suitable, particularly 2B, 4B and 6B. They lay down darker tone with less pressure and blend more easily than harder pencils. If you only buy one shading pencil, a 2B is a good all-rounder: dark enough for shadows, light enough to control.
Most artists pair the B grades with an HB or 2H for light tones, fine details and the initial sketch. One pencil can produce a fair range of values, but a small set makes it much easier to get both clean lights and rich darks.
How pencil grades work
Graphite pencil “lead” is a mixture of graphite and clay. The ratio sets the hardness:
- H (hard): more clay. Lighter, crisper marks that hold a sharp point and smudge less. The higher the number (2H, 4H, 6H), the harder and lighter.
- B (black): more graphite. Darker, softer marks that blend easily but smudge more and wear down faster. The higher the number (2B, 4B, 6B, 8B), the softer and darker.
- HB and F: the middle of the scale. HB is the typical writing pencil. F (“firm”) sits between HB and H.
The full range typically runs from around 9H to 9B, and some brands go further. You only need a few grades to shade well.
Which grade to use for each part of a drawing
| Grade | Typical use in a shaded drawing |
|---|---|
| 2H–H | Light construction lines, the palest tones, detail on smooth paper |
| HB | General sketching, light-to-middle values, first layers of tone |
| 2B | Middle tones, general shading, most of the “body” of a drawing |
| 4B | Shadow sides, cast shadows, deeper values |
| 6B | Core shadows, contact shadows, the darkest accents |
| 8B and softer | Very dark, rich areas. Can be harder to control and shine more easily |
This isn’t a strict rule. The table is a starting point, and many artists overlap grades or use fewer of them. If you’re new to working from light to dark across grades, our beginner’s guide to pencil shading shows how HB, 2B, 4B and 6B fit together in one drawing.
A good starter set for shading
A practical first set:
- 2H for light lines and the lightest tones
- HB for general drawing
- 2B for middle tones
- 4B for shadows
- 6B for the darkest darks
That’s five pencils. You can drop the 2H if you have a light touch with HB. Graded sets of 6 to 12 pencils are widely available and are a convenient way to get these grades plus a few extras to experiment with.
A good way to get to know your pencils is to make a 9-step value scale with each one. You’ll quickly see how dark each grade can go and where the grades overlap.
Does the brand matter?
Less than you might think when you’re starting. Student-grade sets are fine for learning to shade. Artist-grade pencils tend to have more consistent, smoother leads with fewer gritty spots, and they sharpen more cleanly.
Brands that artists commonly mention for graphite drawing include Staedtler Mars Lumograph, Faber-Castell 9000, Derwent Graphic, Tombow Mono, General’s Kimberly and Mitsubishi Hi-Uni. Each has its own character, and opinions differ.
One thing to know: grades aren’t standardized between brands. One brand’s 4B may be noticeably darker or lighter than another’s. If you mix brands, test each pencil on scrap paper so you know how they compare.
Other pencils for shading
Woodless graphite
These are solid sticks of graphite with a thin lacquer coating and no wood casing. Because you can use the side of the whole tip, they cover large areas quickly. They’re useful for big tonal drawings and backgrounds, though they’re more fragile if dropped.
Mechanical pencils
Good for fine, consistent lines and small details, since the point never gets dull. They’re less suited to broad shading because the thin lead only lays down a narrow mark. Leads are often sold in a narrower range of grades than wood pencils, though softer leads such as 2B are widely available.
Charcoal and carbon pencils
If you want deeper, more matte blacks than graphite can give, charcoal pencils go darker and don’t shine. Carbon pencils sit somewhere between graphite and charcoal. Both smudge more readily and erase less cleanly than graphite. They’re worth exploring once you’re comfortable with graphite, but they behave differently enough to treat as a separate medium.
Paper makes a difference too
The same pencil will look different on different papers. Softer B grades generally work best on paper with a bit of tooth (surface texture), which grips the graphite and lets you layer. On very smooth paper, soft graphite can burnish quickly. Burnishing means the tooth fills up and the surface turns shiny, after which it won’t take more graphite. Harder H grades suit smoother papers for fine detail.
A medium-weight drawing or cartridge paper is a good general choice for shading practice.
Technique matters as much as the pencil
A good shading pencil helps, but most of the results come from how you use it:
- Work light to dark. Start with light layers and build up. It’s easier to darken than to lighten.
- Change grade rather than pressing harder. Pressing hard with a light pencil can dent the paper and leave a shiny surface.
- Hold the pencil further back and use the side of the lead for broad, even tone.
- Blend selectively. A blending stump or tortillon can smooth graphite nicely, but heavy blending can make drawings look muddy.
With a 2B, a 4B and a light pencil for the lights, you have everything you need to shade almost any subject.