Shading

How to Make a 9-Step Value Scale in Pencil

Make an even 9-step value scale in pencil: draw the boxes, set white, black and middle gray first, fill the steps between, then check your values and use the scale.

On this page
  1. What a value scale is (and why 9 steps)
  2. What you need
  3. Step-by-step: making the scale
  4. Which pencils to use for each step
  5. How to check your values
  6. Common mistakes
  7. Variations to try
  8. How to use a value scale while drawing

A value scale is a strip of boxes that runs in even steps from white to black. Making one is one of the most useful shading exercises, because it trains your pressure control, shows you what each pencil can do and gives you a reference to check your drawings against. It’s also a common art class assignment.

What a value scale is (and why 9 steps)

“Value” means how light or dark something is, regardless of its color. A value scale breaks the range from white to black into a set number of equal steps.

Nine steps is a popular choice because it puts a clear middle gray at step 5, with an equal number of steps on either side. That makes it easier to build the scale evenly. Scales of 5, 7 or 10 steps are also common. The method below works for any of them.

What you need

  • Pencils in a range of grades, for example 2H, HB, 2B, 4B, 6B (and an 8B if you have one)
  • Smooth-to-medium drawing paper
  • A ruler
  • A kneaded eraser
  • Optional: a hole punch and a scrap of white card, to make a value finder
  • Optional: a blending stump or tissue

Step-by-step: making the scale

1. Draw the boxes

With a ruler and a light pencil, draw a long rectangle and divide it into nine equal boxes, about 2 to 2.5 cm (roughly 1 inch) each. Boxes that touch make it easier to compare neighboring steps than boxes with gaps. Number them 1 to 9 lightly underneath, with 1 as the lightest.

2. Leave step 1 white

Step 1 is the white of the paper. Leave it completely blank.

3. Make the darkest step

Fill step 9 with the darkest value you can make. Use your softest pencil and build it up in several layers, changing stroke direction between layers to fill the paper’s texture. Avoid pressing so hard that the surface goes very shiny. If it does, it may actually look lighter under some lighting. Several firm layers usually work better than one heavy one.

4. Find the middle gray

Now fill step 5 with a value that looks halfway between the white of step 1 and the black of step 9. A 2B or HB with moderate pressure is often about right, but judge by eye, not by pencil grade. This is the hardest step to get right. Many people make it too light at first.

5. Fill the quarter points

Fill step 3 halfway between white and your middle gray, and step 7 halfway between your middle gray and black.

6. Fill the remaining steps

Fill steps 2, 4, 6 and 8, each halfway between its neighbors. Working this way, ends first, then the middle, then the halfway points, keeps the steps much more even than shading from 1 to 9 in order, which tends to run out of room at the dark end.

Shade each box as evenly as possible. Light, overlapping strokes with the side of the lead help, or you can blend lightly with a stump or tissue once the graphite is down.

7. Check and adjust

Step back and look at the whole scale. Each step should look like a clear, equal jump from its neighbors. Darken any step that looks too close to the one before it. Lighten any that’s too dark by pressing and lifting with a kneaded eraser.

Which pencils to use for each step

As a rough guide (grades vary between brands, and pressure matters as much as grade):

Step Value Possible pencil
1 White None (bare paper)
2 Very light gray 2H, light pressure
3 Light gray 2H or HB
4 Light-mid gray HB
5 Middle gray HB firm or 2B light
6 Mid-dark gray 2B
7 Dark gray 4B
8 Very dark gray 6B
9 Near black 6B–8B, layered

Using lighter grades for the light steps helps keep them smooth. Softer pencils used lightly can look grainy, because the graphite sits only on the peaks of the paper’s texture. If you’d like more on choosing grades, see which pencil is most suitable for shading.

How to check your values

It’s surprisingly hard to judge values side by side. A few tricks help:

  • Squint. Half-closing your eyes reduces detail and makes the differences between steps easier to see.
  • Use a value finder. Punch a hole in a strip of white card (or punch a hole in the center of each box on a printed gray scale). Hold it over each step in turn. Isolating one value at a time stops neighboring boxes from influencing how you see it.
  • Take a grayscale photo. Photograph the scale with your phone and view it in black and white. Uneven jumps often become obvious. Keep in mind that cameras don’t record values exactly as your eye sees them.
  • Look from across the room. Distance has a similar effect to squinting.

Common mistakes

  • Middle steps bunched together. Steps 4 to 6 often end up almost the same. Fixing white, black and step 5 first helps prevent this.
  • Dark end not dark enough. Step 9 is often only a dark gray. Use your softest pencil and several layers.
  • Patchy boxes. Uneven pressure gives blotchy tone. Use light, overlapping strokes and build up.
  • Visible outlines. Dark box outlines interfere with judging values. Keep them light, or erase them once the boxes are filled.
  • Burnishing. Pressing hard with a soft pencil can make the surface shiny and stop further layers from taking.

Variations to try

  • Single-pencil scale. Make all nine steps with just one pencil, such as a 2B, by controlling pressure and layers. It’s a good test of control.
  • Gradient scale. Shade a long strip that goes smoothly from white to black with no visible steps.
  • Hatching scale. Make each step using only lines: closer spacing and more crossing layers for darker steps. See how to explain cross-hatching for a simple four-step version.
  • Other media. Try the same scale in charcoal or ink wash to compare their ranges with graphite.

How to use a value scale while drawing

Once you’ve made a scale, keep it next to your drawing:

  • Hold it up against the subject and squint to identify which step each area matches.
  • Check your darkest shadows against step 8 or 9. Beginners’ drawings often stop around step 6 or 7.
  • Use it to plan which areas of a drawing get which values before you start shading.

The next step after a value scale is usually a shaded sphere. Try how to draw a sphere easily, or see the full sequence of exercises in pencil shading for beginners.

The complete guide to shading

Pencil Shading for Beginners: Techniques and Easy Exercises
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →