Why charcoal pencils are a good place to start
Charcoal can feel messy and hard to control the first time you pick it up. Charcoal pencils make it easier. You get the deep, matte blacks and soft tone that charcoal is known for, but the wood casing keeps your fingers fairly clean and gives you a point you can actually steer.
That makes pencils a sensible bridge between the graphite pencil most people grew up with and the looser, broader charcoal sticks. You can sketch small, add detail, and learn how charcoal behaves on paper without the dust and breakage of a bare stick.
This guide covers what to buy, how to sharpen and hold the pencils, the basic shading techniques, a simple first sketch, and some exercises to build control.
Charcoal pencil vs charcoal stick: what’s the difference?
Both are made from charcoal, but they behave quite differently.
- Charcoal pencils contain a core of compressed charcoal, which is charcoal powder mixed with a binder such as clay or gum, inside a wooden or paper casing. They give you a controllable point, are cleaner to hold, and suit detail and smaller sketches.
- Vine and willow sticks are charred twigs with no binder. They make light, soft grey marks that erase easily, which makes them good for loose layouts and big shapes, but they are fragile and dusty.
- Compressed charcoal sticks use the same kind of binder-and-powder mix as the pencil core, just without the casing. They are dark, bold and good for covering large areas quickly.
The short version: pencils for control and detail, sticks for speed and big areas. Many artists use both in one drawing. If you want the detail on the two main stick types, see our comparison of vine and compressed charcoal.
A simple starter kit
You don’t need much. A small, focused kit will teach you more than a big boxed set.
Pencils and grades
Start with two or three charcoal pencils of different softness: one harder for light lines and details, one medium, and one soft for darks. A white charcoal or pastel pencil is optional but handy on toned paper.
Grade labelling isn’t standardised. Some brands use graphite-style labels such as HB, 2B, 4B and 6B, while others simply say hard, medium and soft, or light, medium and dark. A 4B from one maker may not match a 4B from another, so it’s worth testing your pencils side by side on scrap paper and getting to know them on their own terms.
Paper
Charcoal needs some tooth, meaning surface texture, to grab onto. Paper sold as charcoal paper or a medium-weight drawing paper with a little texture is a good start. Very smooth paper (like printer paper) holds little charcoal and fills up quickly, while very rough paper can make detail hard. Toned grey or tan paper is worth trying once you’re comfortable, because it lets you work both darker and lighter than the paper.
Erasers and blending tools
- Kneaded eraser: soft and shapeable. It lifts charcoal by dabbing rather than rubbing, and you can pinch it into a point to pick out highlights.
- Vinyl or plastic eraser: for cleaner, harder-edged corrections.
- Blending stump or tortillon: a tightly rolled paper tool for smoothing tone in small areas.
- Tissue, paper towel or a soft brush: for softening larger areas.
A craft knife and a sanding pad or a piece of fine sandpaper are useful for sharpening (more on that below). A scrap sheet to rest your hand on helps prevent smudges.
Sharpening charcoal pencils without breaking them
Charcoal cores are more brittle than graphite and often break in standard pencil sharpeners, especially cheap ones with dull blades. Many artists sharpen by hand instead:
- Hold the pencil with the point facing away from you.
- Use a sharp craft knife to shave the wood back in short, shallow strokes, rotating as you go. Expose a good length of core, but don’t cut into it.
- Gently shape the exposed core into a point by rubbing it on a sanding pad or fine sandpaper, turning the pencil as you work.
Do this over a bin or a sheet of paper, because the shavings and dust go everywhere. Keep the sandpaper dust in a small jar; it’s useful for toning paper with a brush or tissue. If you prefer a sharpener, a good-quality one with a fresh blade works better than a worn one, and some sharpeners are designed specifically for charcoal and pastel pencils.
Dropping charcoal pencils can crack the core inside the wood, so a cracked point that keeps snapping may be damage further down rather than bad sharpening.
How to hold the pencil
How you hold the pencil changes the marks you get.
- Writing grip (tripod): close to the point, for control and detail. Good for eyes, edges and small accents.
- Overhand grip: pencil held under your palm, more on its side, with your hand further up the shaft. This uses the side of the core and lets you lay down broad, soft tone with your whole arm rather than just your fingers.
- Held far back: grip near the end of the pencil for loose, light layout lines. It’s hard to press firmly this way, which is exactly the point early in a drawing.
Try switching grips during a sketch: loose and far back for the layout, overhand for tone, and a writing grip for the final details.
Basic marks and shading techniques
If you’ve wondered how to shade with a pencil as a beginner, the methods below apply to graphite too. Charcoal just gets darker faster.
Hatching and cross-hatching
Hatching is a set of roughly parallel lines. Closer lines read as darker tone; spaced-out lines read lighter. Cross-hatching adds a second set of lines at an angle over the first, and you can keep adding layers to build darker values. Keep your strokes steady and consistent in direction for a clean look, or let them follow the form of the object to suggest curves.
Stippling and scribbling
Stippling builds tone from dots. It’s slow, but it gives a fine, even texture and is very controllable. Scribbling, or small circular strokes, builds tone faster and gives a looser, more textured feel. Both are good ways to practise light pressure.
Blended tone
Lay down light hatching, then soften it with a stump or tissue. Charcoal blends readily, so you can get smooth gradients quickly. A common beginner habit is blending with a finger; this works, but skin oils can leave patches that are hard to erase or draw over, so a stump or tissue is usually the safer choice.
Whichever technique you use, the key is pressure control. Start light and build up in layers. Charcoal that’s been ground hard into the paper is difficult to lift, so it’s easier to go darker later than to go lighter.
A step-by-step first sketch
Choose a simple subject with clear light and shadow, such as an egg, a mug or an apple lit from one side by a lamp.
- Lay out the shape. Hold a harder pencil far back and sketch the outline and the main shadow shape lightly. Don’t worry about clean lines yet.
- Find the light. Notice where the light comes from. Mark the edge where the light side turns into shadow, plus the cast shadow on the table.
- Block in the shadows. Using the side of a medium pencil, fill the shadow side and cast shadow with a light, even tone.
- Build the middle tones. Add lighter tone where the form starts to turn away from the light. Blend gently if you want a softer look.
- Push the darks. With a soft pencil, darken the core of the shadow and the area right under the object where the cast shadow is darkest.
- Pull out the lights. Use a pointed kneaded eraser to lift the highlight and clean up any light areas that got dusty.
- Refine edges. Sharpen edges where the object meets a contrasting background and soften edges that turn away from you.
Squinting at your subject helps simplify it into light and dark shapes. For a wider overview of this layering process with sticks as well as pencils, see our guide on how to draw with charcoal.
Beginner exercises to practise
Short, repeatable drills build control faster than jumping straight into big drawings.
- Value scale. Draw a row of five to nine boxes and fill them from the white of the paper to the darkest black you can make, with even steps in between. Do one using hatching and one using blended tone.
- Gradient strip. Shade a long strip that fades smoothly from dark to light with no visible steps. This trains pressure control.
- Pressure test. With each pencil, make marks at very light, medium and heavy pressure to see the full range each one can produce.
- Sphere study. Draw a circle and shade it as a ball lit from one side, with a highlight, mid tones, a core shadow, a little reflected light, and a cast shadow.
- Line weight practice. Draw simple objects using only line, varying thickness and darkness so edges facing the light are thinner and those in shadow are heavier.
- Timed sketches. Do several two- to five-minute sketches of household objects. Speed stops you overworking and helps you commit to marks.
Once you’re comfortable with light-to-dark building, try the opposite approach: tone the whole page and erase the lights out. Our guide to subtractive charcoal drawing explains how.
Avoiding smudges and common mistakes
- Rest your hand on a scrap sheet, not directly on the drawing.
- Work from top to bottom (and left to right if you’re right-handed) so your hand isn’t dragging across finished areas.
- Don’t blow the dust off. It scatters dust across the drawing and into the air. Tap the board gently over a bin or let it fall off by tilting the board.
- Don’t go too dark too early. Heavy marks are hard to erase and can flatten the paper’s tooth so later layers won’t stick.
- Don’t rub with erasers if you can dab. Rubbing can smear charcoal and damage the paper surface.
- Step back regularly. Looking at the drawing from a distance shows you value problems you can’t see up close.
Charcoal dust is something to keep under control in general. Working with good ventilation, avoiding breathing in dust, and washing your hands afterwards are sensible habits.
Fixing your sketch (and the hairspray question)
Charcoal sits on top of the paper and can smudge long after you’ve finished. A spray fixative binds it lightly to the surface. There are two broad kinds:
- Workable fixative is designed to be used between layers, so you can keep drawing on top.
- Final fixative is meant for finished work.
Apply light coats from a distance, following the instructions on the can, and do it in a well-ventilated space or outdoors. Fixative can darken charcoal slightly and reduce some sparkle in the lights, so a few thin coats are usually better than one heavy one.
Can you use hairspray? Many people do use hairspray as a cheap substitute, especially for practice sketches, and it can reduce smudging. It’s not designed for artwork, though. Formulations vary, some may leave a sticky or uneven finish, and there are concerns that some could discolour paper over time. For practice pieces it’s a reasonable stopgap; for work you want to keep, an artist’s fixative is the more reliable option. Test on a scrap first either way.
When storing finished sketches, place a sheet of glassine or acid-free tissue over them and keep them flat.
Where to go next
Once you’re comfortable with charcoal pencils, the natural next step is to add sticks: vine charcoal for loose layouts and compressed sticks for strong darks. If you’re curious about the material itself, you can even try making your own charcoal powder for toning paper.
Above all, keep your early drawings simple and do them often. A few short sessions a week with a value scale and a single object will teach you more about charcoal than any amount of materials.