Can you make pen ink from charcoal?
Yes. Charcoal is almost pure carbon, and carbon is the pigment behind many of the oldest black inks. If you grind charcoal very finely, then mix it with water and a binder such as gum arabic, you get a usable ink for dip pens, reed pens and brushes.
It won’t behave quite like a bottle of commercial ink. Homemade charcoal ink tends to be a little greyer and grainier, and it settles in the jar, so you’ll need to stir it. But it’s cheap, it’s satisfying to make, and the slightly rough, warm black has its own character, especially for sketching and calligraphy practice.
How pen ink works: pigment, binder and water
Most pen inks, homemade or commercial, are built from a few basic parts:
- Colourant. Either a pigment (solid particles, like carbon) or a dye (dissolved colour). Charcoal ink is a pigment ink.
- Vehicle. Usually water, which carries the colourant and lets it flow.
- Binder. Something that glues the pigment particles to the paper once the water evaporates. Without it, a carbon ink would dry and then rub off like dust. Gum arabic is the traditional choice for home ink; animal glue and shellac are used in other carbon inks.
- Additives. Optional extras such as a humectant to slow drying and improve flow, or a preservative to stop mould.
Commercial manufacturers control these with far more precision, especially particle size, but the principle is the same. If you want to see how a classic carbon ink is put together, our article on what Indian ink is made of covers it.
What you need
- Charcoal. Vine or willow charcoal is easiest to grind. You can also use charcoal you’ve made yourself from twigs. Avoid barbecue briquettes, which often contain binders and additives.
- Gum arabic. Sold by art suppliers either as a liquid medium or as dry crystals or powder you dissolve in warm water.
- Water. Distilled water is a good idea since it avoids minerals and some microbes, but tap water will work for small test batches.
- A mortar and pestle, or a sheet of glass and a palette knife (a glass muller is ideal if you have one).
- A fine strainer, such as a coffee filter or a piece of fine cloth.
- A small jar with a lid.
- Optional: a few drops of honey or glycerine as a humectant, and a preservative such as a drop of clove oil or a little vinegar.
Keep these tools for art use only and don’t return them to the kitchen.
Step-by-step: making charcoal ink
Recipes vary and there’s no single correct ratio. Treat the amounts below as a starting point and adjust by testing.
Grind the charcoal as finely as you can
This is the most important step. Coarse particles make grainy lines, clog nibs and fall off the paper.
- Break the charcoal into small pieces.
- Grind it in a mortar and pestle until it feels like fine flour.
- Sift it through a fine strainer and regrind what’s left.
Wear a dust mask and grind gently, since fine charcoal dust gets into the air easily. Some people add a few drops of water at this stage and grind it as a wet paste, which also keeps the dust down.
Mull the powder with binder
- Put about a teaspoon of charcoal powder on your glass slab or in the mortar.
- Add a small amount of gum arabic solution, roughly half a teaspoon to begin with.
- Work it together with a palette knife or muller in small circles until it forms a smooth, even paste. Take your time; this breaks up clumps and coats each particle with binder.
- Add a drop of honey or glycerine if you’re using one.
Too little binder and the dry ink will smudge. Too much and it can become glossy, sticky or slow to dry. You’ll find the balance after a couple of batches.
Thin, strain and bottle
- Add water a few drops at a time, mixing as you go, until the ink flows like a thin cream or milk.
- Pour it through a coffee filter or fine cloth into your jar to catch any remaining grit. This is slow, so be patient.
- Add a preservative if you’re using one, then seal the jar.
Test on paper
Dip a pen or brush and make a few strokes on the paper you plan to use. Check:
- Does it flow smoothly from the nib?
- Is the black dense enough?
- Once completely dry, does it smudge if you rub it lightly?
If it smudges, add a little more gum arabic. If it’s too pale, add more charcoal paste. If it’s too thick to flow, add a few drops of water.
Which pens and brushes to use it with
Charcoal ink works best with tools that are easy to clean:
- Dip pens with steel nibs
- Reed, bamboo or quill pens
- Brushes, from fine detail brushes to broad wash brushes
- Sticks and twigs for loose, expressive marks
Avoid fountain pens. Pigment particles in homemade ink are far larger and less uniform than in fountain pen inks, and the binder can dry inside the feed. This can clog the pen, and cleaning it out may be difficult. Technical pens are also likely to clog.
Clean nibs and brushes with water soon after use, before the gum arabic dries.
Troubleshooting homemade charcoal ink
| Problem | Likely cause | What to try |
|---|---|---|
| Grainy or scratchy lines | Particles too coarse | Grind longer, sift and strain again |
| Ink settles quickly | Normal for coarse pigment ink | Stir or shake before every use; grind finer |
| Rubs off when dry | Not enough binder | Add more gum arabic solution |
| Glossy, sticky or cracks | Too much binder | Add more charcoal paste and water |
| Pale, greyish black | Too little pigment, or charcoal not fully charred | Add more paste; try a different charcoal |
| Won’t flow from nib | Too thick, or nib is greasy | Thin with water; clean the nib |
| Mould or bad smell | No preservative, contaminated water | Make smaller batches, use distilled water, add preservative |
Charcoal ink vs soot-based ink
Historically, most high-quality black carbon inks were made from soot (lampblack or pine soot) rather than ground charcoal. Soot forms as extremely fine particles when oil, resin or wood burns with limited air, so it gives a smoother, denser black than hand-ground charcoal can. Traditional East Asian ink sticks, for example, are made from soot bound with animal glue.
Ground charcoal is coarser, so it gives a slightly warmer, more textured line. If you want a smoother black at home, people sometimes collect soot by holding a cool metal surface above a candle or oil lamp flame and scraping it off. Treat that with care: open flames, hot metal and fine soot are all hazards, and soot should not be inhaled.
How does this compare to iron gall ink?
Iron gall ink works in a completely different way. Instead of carbon particles, it’s made from tannins (traditionally extracted from oak galls) reacting with iron sulfate, usually with gum arabic as a binder. The ink often goes on pale and darkens as it oxidises on the paper. It was the standard writing ink in Europe for centuries.
It has a downside: over long periods, iron gall ink can be acidic and corrode the paper it’s written on, which is a known issue in old manuscripts. Carbon inks, including charcoal ink, are generally chemically stable on paper by comparison.
Storage and shelf life
Store charcoal ink in a sealed jar away from heat. Expect some settling; stir it before each use. Small batches are better than big ones, because homemade inks with gum arabic and water can grow mould over time, especially without a preservative. If the ink smells off or shows fuzzy growth, throw it away and make a fresh batch.
Label the jar with the date and your recipe so you can repeat what worked. Once you’ve made one batch, you’ll likely want to experiment with different charcoals, binder amounts and papers. That’s half the fun.